"In FDNY 9-11 Transcripts, Bravery, Drama, Confusion -- and Raw,"

August 12, 2005, Associated Press,
by Michael Weissenstein and Sara Kugler,

NEW YORK (AP) -- They were trudging up the stairs of the north tower, weighed down with gear and pausing every four floors to catch their breath. They had no idea the south tower had been hit.

"It was single file, civilians going down and firemen going up," firefighter Marcel Claes recalled. "The civilians were orderly and blessing us and helping the injured down."

At the 35th story, on his knees and talking with other firefighters about how best to get equipment up the tower, Claes and his brethren felt a rumble---like an earthquake, or a train going through your living room, he said.

It was then, as the south tower of the World Trade Center was collapsing in a giant cloud of debris, that he heard the voice of a chief from another battalion: "Drop everything and get out."

The story was just one that emerged Friday as the Fire Department released 12,000 pages of oral histories recorded by firefighters who responded to the trade center attack and lost 343 of their brethren---the most finely sketched portrait yet of the horror and chaos of Sept. 11, 2001.

There were stories of firefighters' dramatic attempts to rescue civilians, of their decisions to evacuate as ordered or their choices to stay in the towers, of their sheer terror when the buildings fell.

Trapped in the mall below the trade center after the collapse of the south tower, firefighter James Murphy and a group of firefighters started hunting for the exits. Frightened civilians began grabbing onto them, he said.

"We were saying, 'Don't worry, we're with the Fire Department. Everybody is going to get out,'" he recalled. But, he said, "We were just as scared as anybody else. We were just victims too. Basically the only difference between us and the victims is we had flashlights."

Some firefighters spoke of sharing a cell phone to call their wives and say goodbye---or of saying goodbye to each other. Timothy Brown recalled saying to fellow firefighter Terry Hatton, "I love you, brother. It might be the last time I see you."

At many points in their oral histories, firefighters were interrupted by the interviewers and asked to diagram or pinpoint on a map where they responded, and in some cases, where they last saw members who were lost in the attack. The interviews began in early October 2001, weeks after the attack, when many victims were still listed as simply missing.

The oral histories were made public along with hours of Fire Department radio transmissions, their release compelled by a lawsuit filed three years ago by The New York Times and long contested by the city.

Some of the material had been released before, and the records released Friday were unlikely to fundamentally change the understanding of the Sept. 11 attack.

Still, the histories offered a poignant catalog of firefighters' still-fresh memories of the horrifying day. And the radio transmissions added new texture to the historical record, beginning at 8:46 a.m. with an urgent but calm description of a plane crashing into the World Trade Center.

"The World Trade Center tower Number One is on fire!" one firefighter radioed.

As the depth of the crisis became clear, the voices on the radios thickened with panic.

"Send every available ambulance, everything you got to the World Trade Center," a firefighter calls from Engine 1. "Now!"

The firefighters became national icons after Sept. 11, 2001, hailed as heroes for rushing into the burning towers as others scrambled to get out. The transcripts also made plain the sheer fear they felt.

Lt. Brian Becker described being about 30 floors up in the north tower, with exhausted firefighters lying on the floor with their masks off, when they were started by a loud explosion. They thought their tower was collapsing.

"Looking up, guys were diving into the stairway, and then it was like---everybody was very scared by then. I'm talking the firemen, and then we were very worried about what was going on. We didn't know, but apparently that was the other building falling."

Family members of lost firefighters pored over the records Friday, some tearing up at descriptions and sounds of the attack and the response. At an office building in midtown Manhattan, a half-dozen family members and two fire officers bent over laptops to examine the material.

"It's very emotional. It's very difficult," said Sally Regenhard, mother of 28-year-old Christian Regenhard, killed along with most of his company's firefighters that day. "But it's no harder than knowing every day that my son is gone."

A group of victims' families who have become advocates for reforming building codes and emergency response had eagerly awaited the release of the records in hopes they would challenge the notion that many firefighters in the north tower heard, but chose to ignore, an evacuation order issued after the south tower collapsed.

Some city officials, including former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, have suggested some firefighters ignored the mayday call in acts of personal heroism. But the group of families has sought to lay blame on the city for providing firefighters with faulty radios.

Thomas Piambino said he never heard any radio communication telling him to get out of the tower---"absolutely nothing," he recalled. He and others near him did leave the tower before it fell, but he said he was not sure why.

"I can't pinpoint anything," he said. "It was just---I don't know what it was. It was just the culmination of intuition or what. I just decided it was time to go."

Lt. Warren Smith recalled leading other firefighters up the north tower to the 31st floor when they received an order to evacuate. The building came down about a minute after he was outside.

He later tried to radio missing colleagues. The communications systems were working better.

"At this point, the radio was pretty open because there weren't a lot of survivors, really," he said.

In many cases, the difference between living and dying was a matter of turning left when another firefighter went right, or stopping to go back and retrieve a piece of forgotten equipment, or to just stand and stare up at the horror.

"All these things contributed, I think, to our survival," Becker said. "Every little, every second made a difference."

The New York Times and families of Sept. 11 victims sued the city in 2002 to release the records, which were collected by the Fire Department in the days after the collapse of the twin towers.

The city withheld them, claiming the release would violate firefighters' privacy and jeopardize the prosecution of Zacarias Moussaoui, who ultimately pleaded guilty to conspiring with the Sept. 11 hijackers.

In March, the state's highest court ordered the city to release the oral histories and radio transmissions but said the city could edit out potentially painful and embarrassing portions.

The Fire Department, in a statement, said it hoped the release of the records would not cause firefighters and their families additional pain.

"The Department believes that the materials being released today ... will serve to further confirm the bravery and courage of our members who responded to the World Trade Center," the statement said.

Associated Press writers Erin McClam, Frank Eltman, Tom Hays, Verena Dobnik and Jennifer Bogar contributed to this report.


A much abbreviated version this article [only the first seven paragraphs] is still found at
http://www.firehouse.com/node/45111 However, the original link where I copied the complete article is now guarded by a "Robots.txt Query Exclusion."


We're sorry, access to http://cms.firehouse.com/web/online/News/In-FDNY-9-11-Transcripts--Bravery--Drama--Confusion----and-Raw-Fear/46$43995 has been blocked by the site owner via robots.txt.